Graduated Learning: Life after College

I got my degree, I got a job…now what?

Paying someone to manage my portfolio: My review of Financial Engines February 21, 2013

Filed under: Personal Finance — Stephanie @ 10:05 pm
Tags: , ,

A while back I discussed trying a portfolio managing service through my 401k.  Since they were giving me a 3-month free trial, I figured I’d try it out.

I had forgotten to write a review of the program until a friend of mine got a similar offer, and she wanted to hear what I thought of it.  So, here we go!

When I signed up, I think I told them my age, and what my other retirement accounts looked like, and I told them to go ahead and do their thing.  They changed the ratios of the funds that I’d “buy” each pay period.  Then every month, they’d slightly re-balance my portfolio, so as to not change everything over all at once.

The first time I called to cancel (before the 3 month trial period ended), they offered to give me another 3 months, so I kept it.  They hadn’t finished their re-balancing, so they wanted me to stay with the program to see if I’d like it more after they fully re-balanced my portfolio.  The 3 months passed, my portfolio got a bit less lopsided, but then it got to be a little over 3 months, so I ended up getting charged for some of the portfolio management (whoops!).   I paid a total of $9.25 in fees for my forgetfulness… not terrible, but annoying.  ALWAYS set a reminder for when you want to cancel something so you don’t get charged!

What I liked:  I got to be lazy, and let them make decisions for me.  I knew that my portfolio was  not set up very well, but I think I was a bit too chicken to actually change anything about it.  Knowing these people have experience in portfolio management and that they would do it in a smart way was helpful.  Because honestly, had I not signed up, my 401k would have remained very unbalanced and poorly planned. Let them worry, that’s their job!

What I didn’t like:  I couldn’t change anything on my own; I basically had signed over all control to them, so I couldn’t change anything directly myself.  So, if I wanted to change things, I’d probably have to call (which I didn’t).  They basically had a plan, and worked towards that plan (certain diversification plan).  Also, the way they do the reallocation, they do it bit by bit once a month, instead of all at once.  Which felt a bit slow to me, but I guess that’s a safer way to do it?

Also, having my 401(k) on autopilot, I sort of ignored my other retirement funds (my Rollover and Roth IRAs), and then realized once I stopped using Financial Engines, that I really should have been paying attention to all my accounts!

I think this program is good for getting your funds on the right track, and they do provide advice for your other accounts (they had ideas on my IRA since you could import your accounts for them to evaluate), but sometimes the advice doesn’t work (like recommending a fund that was unavailable required a huge minimum)

If you get a free trial for a portfolio management service, I think you should try it out, as long as you set a reminder for yourself before the trial period ends.  It’s a good way to make some changes to your portfolio that you may have been afraid to go ahead with, and if you don’t like it, you can cancel.  Keep in mind that the amount of time it will take for their entire re-allocation plan might be longer than the trial period.

Have you ever paid someone to manage your portfolio?  Or tried a program like Financial Engines? What did you think?  If you haven’t, would you?


3 Responses to “Paying someone to manage my portfolio: My review of Financial Engines”

  1. Anonymous Says:

    Good review. I was also part of their trial offer, but was not very impressed. Like the review states, my biggest problem is that once they start making changes, you have no control over your 401k anymore. They also don’t verify the changes they are about to make with me, and some of the changes they made to my account were based on old data. Not sure why they didn’t review my latest data before making those changes. They also did not take into account my other retirement accounts. I still don’t understand how they could make accurate adjustments to my account without knowing my ENTIRE financial situation. Overall, I would not recommend them to anyone. If you want to work with financial planner, it’s better to find one in your area, meet with them in person, and get recommendations. Then make they changes your self based on these suggestions. Probably will cost you the same, but you have full control over your account.


  2. Anonymous Says:

    Agree with anonymous, except the part about cost. FE cost Stephanie less than lunch over a 6 month period. A couple sit down meetings with a non-commission professional CFA will cost much more, probably the price of a new tires or a trip to a pro-sports game with the family. That’s not to say it’s not worth it to pay for quality advice.

    I believe FE is a great value at the price, but only if your financial picture doesn’t get a lot more complex than retirement planning. As soon as you add real estate, education funding, life insurance, tax strategy, precious metals, and income generating investments to the picture, pay the few hundred bucks to consult with a non-commission based CFA. Peace of mind, well considered decisions, and happy returns are worth the cost of a one gameday.


  3. Nicole Says:

    My husband’s employment company gave an option to use FE to offer advice and manage 401 investments. Money has grown at a tremendous rate in comparison to what it was doing the 15 years before without FE. This year, our average rate of return has been 18%. That’s ALOT of money. If you’re familiar with Rule 72, that means our money will double every 3.9 years. Heck my money in teacher retirement is stuck at 3%. I’m rolling over that money as part if my new year, 2018, financial goal. Put your money to work for you. You already did the hard part, the labor earning the original cash.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s